Rabbi Oury Cherki
Faith in the Sages
One of the forty-eight traits by which the Torah is acquired is "faith in the sages" [Avot 6:6]. This is usually taken to mean that one of our basic elements of faith is that the Jewish sages do not make mistakes. But it is eminently clear that this interpretation cannot be right, for there is no person on earth who is completely immune from making a mistake. In fact, we have seen many cases where the sages admitted their mistakes. Who is greater than Moshe himself, about whom it is written, "And Moshe heard, and it was good in his eyes" [Leviticus 10:20]? Rashi explains, "He was not ashamed to admit that he had not heard this before." The following also appears in the responsa literature: "The praise of the rabbis is that they admit their mistakes." That is, the fact that the wise men admit that they were wrong is to their credit.
The very existence of the tractate of Horayot, which contains a list of mistaken rulings by the high courts, also shows that errors occur. In fact, the Torah has forbidden us to follow a halachic ruling if we are absolutely certain that the court has made a mistake. "We might think that if they tell you that right is left and that left is right that you should follow them. However, it is written, ‘to go to the right and to the left.’ They should tell you that the right is the right and the left is the left." [Yerushalmi Horayot 1:1]. And when the Sifri instructs us to follow "even though they show you what you have seen in your eyes is right and tell you it is left," this is referring only to matters of personal discretion.
This position, the feeling that our wise men are never wrong, is dangerous from two points of view. One aspect is simple, and that is that when a person encounters a mistake made by a wise man his entire spiritual world might crumble before his eyes. The second aspect is deeper, in that it attributes to a created entity a characteristic which is only true in reference to the Creator Himself. This is the meaning of what the Rambam wrote: "Only He is the truth" [Hilchot Yesodei HaTorah 1:4].
What, then, is the wondrous trait of faith in the sages which is needed in order to gain possession of the Torah? Rabbi Yehuda Ashkenazi explains that it means to believe that the sages are wise. That is, their words are not pronounced in a chance or haphazard way. Therefore, if one thinks that it is necessary to reject their words, the idea that is being rejected must be scrutinized in great depth, because we can be sure that it is based on great wisdom and can teach us an important lesson. If the wise men taught us that "there is nothing that does not have its proper place" [Avot 4:3], this must certainly apply to the words of the sages themselves.
While we commonly see a contradiction between admiration and free criticism, our sages have taught us that one of these traits enables the other one. They said, "Let your house be a meeting place for wise men, and you should roll around in the dust of their feet" [Avot 1:4]. Here is how this was interpreted by Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin: "the word ‘lehitavek’ is related to the word for a struggle. No student should ever blindly accept the words of his rabbi if he has questions about his approach, and there are even times when the student is right and not the rabbi. But while we have permission to bring evidence to prove our position, we must still maintain an attitude of humility – to be ‘in the dust of their feet.’"